By Hannah Harrinton
Genre YA contemporary
Pages 288
First Sentence Keeping secrets isn't my specialty.
Synopsis
Known as the high school gossip, Chelsea Knot has a big secret. In a drunken stupor she blurts out that secret about a boy that results in him getting beat up and ending up in the hospital. Even though she turns in the perpetrators she still can't rid herself of the guilt. So she takes a vow of silence. She won't be spreading any more rumors. She won't speak at all. Saying sorry isn't enough.
What it has going for it
Well, I loved the idea of this one. I saw so much room for a snotty gossipy girl to learn and grow...but alas.
What's lacking
My biggest issue with this one, aside from the fact that the main character really doesn't learn from her experience, was that nothing followed through. For example. Chelsea, our chatty Cathy, gets her idea to take a vow of silence from an article about a monk. He took a vow of silence and learned to meditate and self evaluate. So, of course at the beginning I'm thinking: "aw sweet, she's going to realize that not only should she keep her mouth shut but that maybe her arrogant judgey attitude was crap!" Alas, our character never learns a thing. She had the decency to report the perpetrators, at least, and had to endure a minor amount of bullying but other than that there was no change of character. Sure, she got a new group of friends that welcomed her with open arms, which she didn't deserve, and yes, she isn't quite so high and mighty in the end but the changes in her attitude were concocted by the author. Never does Chelsea look at herself and realize what a horrible person she was. Alright, I'm going to stop. The book really wasn't that terrible. I just really wanted the character to self evaluate and grow but she just lucked out and moved on.
Yea or Nay?
You won't be missing anything by skipping this book.
It seemed like this book was just kind of meh foryou. I think ill be taking your yay or nay advice
ReplyDeleteGreat Review!
Michelle @ Book Briefs
Yeah, just skip it.
DeleteI can see why you didn't like this one. I don't think I'd like it either. I'm all about self-reflection and I don't like it when characters don't change. :)
ReplyDeleteI know, right?
DeleteI actually quite liked this one, but I agree with you about Chelsea. I did wish she would have realised just how bad she was before, but it sort of got glossed over.
ReplyDeleteI wanted to like it and I didn't hate it. I just wanted more change.
DeleteI think I had this one on my TBR, and it looks like it's good that I didn't pick it up! I don't like it when characters don't learn SOMETHING from what they do. It's just disappointing. Oh well!
ReplyDeleteYeah, it's so annoying.
DeleteI felt the same way about this book -- great premise, poor execution. Hate that!
ReplyDeleteIndeed!
DeleteI like the idea of a gossip taking a vow of silence, but it sort of defeats the purpose if she doesn't learn anything. Think I'll skip this one. Thanks for your honest review!
ReplyDeleteYeah, it was pretty sad.
Delete+JMJ+
ReplyDeleteOh, man! Does your review hit the bull's eye for me or what?
If a character makes a huge mistake that hurts other people and doesn't self-evaluate, then to me, there was no point in writing his story. I know that it happens a lot in real life, but that's no excuse for fiction's dropping the moral ball like that.
Incidentally, this was the reason I really hated Stephenie Meyer's New Moon the first time I read it. I thought that Bella Swan got away with a lot of terrible things and not only never felt sorry for them, but also honestly didn't believe she had done anything wrong. (!!!!!!!!) It took me years to read the next book in the series, Eclipse, but I was ultimately glad that I did because although it started out with her still being selfish and stubborn, she eventually did realise her part in the mess and feel sorry. It was at this point that I stopped loathing Bella. LOL! When people can admit that they've been wrong and pinpoint the exact character flaw at the root of it, they can't be all bad.